Application Cycle One: 06/16/2017
- Undergraduate college: Small Liberal Arts
- Undergraduate Area of study: Biological/Life Sciences
- Total MCAT SCORE: 520
-
- MCAT Section Scores:
B/B 130,
C/P 128,
P/S 132, CARS 130
- Overall GPA: 3.90
-
- Science GPA: 3.90
-
Summary of Application Experience
Timeline:
6/17/17: AMCAS submitted (including committee letter and MCAT scores)
7/10/17: AMCAS verified
8/04/17: Complete at all schools except UW, which requires a mission statement pre-secondary for OOR applicants
Things that went well:
Pre-writing secondaries: I recommend doing this for as many schools as possible! The prompts do not change much from year to year and most can be found on the SDN school-specific threads or even directly on the school websites. I only ended up pre-writing for 3 schools, but this relieved so much stress when the secondaries started pouring in after my AMCAS was verified.
Staying with a student host: This was a great way to cut costs for an already insanely expensive process and also get a better feel for the school before interview day. All of my hosts walked or drove me to the admissions office the day of, which also relieved the stress of potentially getting lost. I thanked each of my hosts with a card and small gift under 20 dollars- e.g. Starbucks tumbler, candy or gift card to a nearby restaurant.
Thanking people who contributed to the interview day: Has little to no sway in your chance of acceptance but it is a kind gesture. I sent brief thank-you emails to interviewers if I felt we really clicked or if there was something to follow up on. In all honestly, I did not send thank-yous to the majority of my interviewers and this did not seem to have any impact on my admissions decisions.
Enjoying the process: While it can be grueling and stressful, the application cycle is a chance to do some serious self-reflection, make new connections and explore new cities. Be proud of yourself for having the persistence to get this far!
** Note: To remain somewhat anonymous, I did not list my actual home state or my state schools that I applied to.
Application Complete, Rejected
University of Southern California
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/28/2017
- Interview Invite: No
- Interview Attended: No
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: 11/16/2017
- View School >
University of California, Los Angeles
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 08/03/2017
- Interview Invite: No
- Interview Attended: No
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: Yes
- Summary of Experience:
Secondary received 7/17/17
Got the secondary in the first wave, then got the silent R. You win some, you lose some.
- View School >
Invited for Interview, Withdrew
Emory University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/16/2017
- Interview Invite: 10/16/2017
- Interview Attended: No
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
I hear great things about Emory SOM and Grady Memorial Hospital! The close proximity to the CDC appeals to me for my public health interests. However, as this was one of my last interview invites, I was running out of money and vacation days. Ultimately, I decided to withdraw and give my interview slot to another applicant.
- View School >
Attended Interview, Rejected
Harvard University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/16/2017
- Interview Invite: 11/26/2017
- Interview Attended: 01/05/2018
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: 03/02/2018
- Summary of Experience:
I ended up having to reschedule my interview due to severe weather conditions leading to my flight being cancelled. The office of admissions was very accommodating and helpful in getting me a new interview date. For winter interviews, I would recommend scheduling for the earliest possible date in case you have to reschedule.
Interview day: The day begins with an orientation where interviewees receive the times, locations and names of their two interviewers. A few unlucky applicants were “on call†and had to wait to receive a text later in the day with the times and locations of their interviews. Aside from the morning orientation and a lunch with current students, interviewees are able to plan their own day based on their interests and when their interviews are scheduled. There are two open-file interviews that may either be on campus or at one of Harvard’s several affiliated hospitals. Cab vouchers are provided to get to the off-campus interviews and the admissions staff orders the cab ahead of time. We were repeatedly advised to relax and be ourselves, as Harvard does NOT do stress interviews. As promised, both of my interviews were very laid-back, with the main focus being on my story and path to medicine.
Pros: Its Harvard. Condensed one year pre-clinical gives extra time for research, dual degrees, extra electives. Flipped-classroom style allows more active learning. Students here were surprisingly very friendly, normal and laid back. Boston is an awesome city for young people. Top residency programs in pretty much every field.
Cons: Possibly expensive. Cost of living in Boston is high, but most first years live in Vanderbilt Hall which is cheaper.
Update: Sadly rejected, but did not have high expectations. It was an honor just to be invited to interview and now making a final decision will be that much easier!
- View School >
Attended Interview, Withdrew
Dartmouth College
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/12/2017
- Interview Invite: 08/15/2017
- Interview Attended: 09/14/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Interview Day: The interview day begins on campus with the typical orientation and financial aid sessions. After this, we were shuttled to the medical center where we had a tour and then lunch in the hospital with current students. After lunch, there were two interviews: one open-file and one closed-file. My closed-file interview was a bit awkward since my interviewer did not know anything about me and it was her first time doing the closed-file format. Most of the other interviewees I talked to had similar experiences with the closed-file, so maybe they will change to two open-file interviews in the future.
Pros: The campus is beautiful and Hanover is charming. What impressed me most was how genuinely friendly and helpful the students were! The student body seems fun and tight-knit. I like the year-long anatomy as opposed to the more typical 7-10 weeks.
Cons: Distance from a major airport, lack of merit-based financial aid, lack of affordable on-campus housing (car would basically be a requirement here) and lack of diversity in the patient population, though Dartmouth does require and help coordinate rotations in other cities.
Update: Decided to withdraw, as I would not choose Geisel over my current options.
- View School >
Attended Interview, Waitlisted, Withdrew
Duke University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/18/2017
- Interview Invite: 08/20/2017
- Interview Attended: 09/25/2017
- Waitlisted: 02/25/2018
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: No
- View School >
Mayo Medical School
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/22/2017
- Interview Invite: 08/13/2017
- Interview Attended: 10/01/2017
- Waitlisted: 02/15/2018
- Accepted: No
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Applied MN campus only. First interview invite!
12/18/17- Highly ranked email received from interviewer. Replied saying Mayo was still one of my top schools, did not send formal letter of interest or intent.
1/5/18- Generic highly ranked email received
Interview day: The interview day here was very enjoyable! I had one interview with a Mayo physician and one with a third-year student, both interviews were open-file. Between interviews there were several built-in breaks, allowing time to explore the beautiful facilities with other interviewees.
Pros: Selective blocks allow students to customize their education and have breaks between major curriculum blocks. Mayo has historically been generous with financial aid (though this may change since they are switching to need-based-only aid this year). The facilities are incredible and centered around patient comfort--the main hospital is nicer than most hotels. Mayo funds three trips per student per year-- to both of the other campuses (AZ and FL) and to any designated underserved city as long as it is not on the US travel watch list.
Cons: Rochester is small and isolated compared to most of the other schools I visited. While I like the idea of having a tight-knit cohort, I think the class size here might become suffocatingly small for me, especially given the location.
Update: Decided to decline the waitlist offer. I am honored to have had the opportunity to experience Mayos unique culture, but ultimately I did not feel it was my best fit.
- View School >
Accepted
Columbia University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/10/2017
- Interview Invite: 09/06/2017
- Interview Attended: 10/13/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 02/20/2018
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Interview Day: Fell in love with Columbia after interview day! Current students kept dropping by throughout the morning to chat, answer our questions and pump us up for the interview. Theres only one interview and its one-on-one traditional open file with a faculty member.
Pros: The new Roy and Diana education center is nothing short of amazing. Students here seem to have great quality of life due to the unranked P/F preclinical and flexible quizzes that can be taken at home. P&S club has endless opportunities for extracurricular involvement--numerous student-run clinics, high school pipeline programs and other ways to get involved in the Washington Heights community. Endless research opportunities. Consistently amazing match lists. VERY generous need-based aid--the new Vagelos fund replaced all need-based loans with scholarships! On top of this, they also give merit-based aid .
Cons: Longstanding reputation for being a competitive environment, though unsure if this remains true. The living situation in Bard is pretty bad--communal bathrooms, tiny rooms, ONE kitchen for the entire residence hall! Luckily there are other options including the towers or off campus which is still relatively affordable. Got a slightly pretentious vibe at Revisit.
Update: With need and merit-based aid combined, essentially got full cost of attendance covered. Will be super difficult deciding between here and NYU!
- View School >
Boston University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/12/2017
- Interview Invite: 08/15/2017
- Interview Attended: 09/18/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 01/03/2018
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
This was my first time in Boston so I came early and spent the weekend exploring Boston before my Monday interview. I actually ended up meeting a few BU medical students during my weekend out, which was fun!
Interview day: The day was unique in that we only had one interview. The style was traditional, open-file. This was one of my most challenging interviews of the cycle in terms of questions asked. Specifically, my interviewer gave me several ethical dilemmas and really pushed me to hash out my ideas. Other interviewees also mentioned that they were asked several ethical questions.
Pros: Boston is an amazing city! BU has a beautiful campus and an MD/MPH would be easily doable here, with the public health building right across the quad from the medical school. Boston medical center is the biggest safety-net hospital in New England, fitting well with my interest in urban underserved medicine.
Cons: The students I encountered seemed more stressed and less friendly than at other schools, though I was also very tired which could have warped my perception. Cost is a major con for me, given the high tuition combined with the high cost of living in Boston.
Update: Accepted with Deans Scholarship--15k per year! Missed the call from Dean Witzberg but ended up getting the acceptance and scholarship emails the following day.
Ultimately decided to decline the offer and hopefully make another applicant very happy!
- View School >
University of Chicago
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/16/2017
- Interview Invite: 10/06/2017
- Interview Attended: 11/15/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 12/18/2017
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
I initially lost hope for Pritzker after seeing so many people on SDN get interview invites within weeks or even days of submitting. The three month wait was not fun, but I was thrilled when I finally got an interview invite! After the interview, Pritzker became tied with Duke for my top choice school based on fit. The school makes an effort to partner with the South Chicago community in addressing their health concerns; the students seem very kind and motivated; the cohort size is small but not TOO small; and the overall vibe is supportive and welcoming. On a more superficial level, the campus is stunning! Heres to another three month wait until decisions come out for my group.
Update 12/19/2017: Accepted with full tuition scholarship!! Got the call much earlier than expected! Literally cried on the phone with Dr Carter. Will definitely be attending second look in April.
- View School >
University of Colorado
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/18/2017
- Interview Invite: 08/28/2017
- Interview Attended: 09/08/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 10/24/2017
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Interview day: This was the first interview I attended and I loved my experience at CU! There are two one-on-one, open-file interviews and both interviews take place in the morning. One of my interviewers was a PhD/faculty member and one was a retired physician. Both were very relaxed and conversational.
Pros: The students here seem friendly, helpful and outgoing. A few students even gave us high-fives and words of encouragement as we passed them in the halls. The facilities are very new and beautiful with views of downtown Denver and the Rocky Mountains. I am interested in the UNITE (urban underserved) track and they also offer LEADS (business), global health, research, and rural tracks.
Cons: The pre-clinical curriculum is not true pass/fail (instead it is honors/high pass/pass/fail with internal ranking). I have heard that they are switching to true pass/fail, possibly by summer 2018 but I think they are keeping the internal ranking.
Update 2/2018: Offered Deans Distinguished Scholarship Award!
Update 4/2018: Withdrew
- View School >
University of Michigan
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/20/2017
- Interview Invite: 08/20/2017
- Interview Attended: 09/29/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 11/11/2017
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Tour/Pizza social: The attire for the walking tour and dinner is very casual; my student tour guide was wearing sweats and most of the applicants were wearing jeans and comfortable shoes. The pizza was delicious and free! There were many current students at the dinner, so it was a great chance to ask questions about U of M and get a better feel for the student body.
Interview day: This was one of the most well-structured interview days and by far the best free swag. After the morning introduction, interviewees were split into two groups--one group started with the Multiple Mini Interview while the other group started with the two traditional open-file interviews. Both the MMI and traditional interviews were pretty relaxed. After interviews, we re-convened for a lunch with current students. The afternoon un-tour is a fun alternative to the traditional facilities tours. My group spent time following a medical resident on pseudo-rounds. The resident brought us to meet a few patients in various departments and we had the unique opportunity to listen to their stories and hear their perspectives on U of M.
Pros: Faculty here seem very supportive and accessible and the students seem very fun and involved in many interests outside of school. Another draw for me is the accelerated 1-year pre-clinical curriculum (similar to Duke and Harvard), which gives an extra year to pursue research or a dual degree, and time to explore specialties not included in the core clerkships. U of M gives generous need and merit-based financial aid. Cost of living in Ann Arbor is cheap. Ranked highly by residency directors. Top residency programs in several specialities.
Cons: Flex-quizzes (weekly online quizzes that can be taken any time, generally between Friday and Sunday) could be seen as a pro or a con. I tend to procrastinate, so I consider it a con--I think I would burn out from quizzing on Sunday and then jumping into new content every Monday. Students here did seem a bit more stressed than at other schools, but it could have just been my timing arriving right after their flex quiz had opened.
Update 3/9/18: Awarded merit scholarship, about 135K total.
Update: Withdrew. I was not sure how I felt about Ann Arbor and the undergraduate vibe, I am leaning toward going to a bigger city for med school. Also, even with the financial aid, as an out of state resident, this would have been one of my more expensive options.
- View School >
New York University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/22/2017
- Interview Invite: 10/03/2017
- Interview Attended: 10/30/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 01/25/2018
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Interview day: The day at NYU felt very short since it did not start until 10:30AM. I did not get to interact with very many current students or get a complete feel for the school in the given time, so I was very glad that I scheduled a meet-up after the interview day with a student liaison (also more free food!). The interview itself was Multiple Mini Interview format and the questions were pretty standard. I read and watched a few practice MMIs online during my plane ride to get the basic idea. When answering questions, I found it helpful to draw from my experiences scribing, shadowing and teaching (e.g. In a similar situation, I saw a physician do X which worked well.)
Pros: Training at Bellvue Hospital, a public hospital, provides the opportunity to learn how to be an effective care provider in the urban underserved setting. Bellevue Hospital, Tische and the VA are all within walking distance of the medical school/on-campus housing. 15% of students are awarded full cost of attendance scholarships! There seems to be a strong focus on student well-being. They have post-quiz parties funded by NYU (technically funded by tuition, still a cool perk) such as happy hour or going apple picking at an orchard in Princeton.
Cons: Location might be overwhelming for me.
Update: Selected to be recipient of the Deans Scholarship, which covers FULL COST OF ATTENDANCE for four years! Also loved this school on Revisit weekend--the students seem very friendly, fun and well-balanced. They have quizzes every other Friday, which means they essentially get every other weekend off and have time to pursue many non-medical interests. The facilities are state-of-the art, the curriculum seems very up to date and I prefer the 1.5 preclinical timeline (less stressful than 1 year preclinical, more time for research/elective rotations than traditional 2 year). Will likely be matriculating here!
- View School >
Cornell University
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 07/30/2017
- Interview Invite: 10/08/2017
- Interview Attended: Yes
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 03/08/2018
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Interview Day: The interview day was loosely formatted, with each applicant having 2 open-file interviews randomly assigned at various times/places. I opted to have my interviews in the morning for traveling purposes. The interviews were brief (30 minutes if I recall correctly) and focused on specifics of my app. The rest of the day consisted of a tour, lunch with current students and the usual informational panels. I went into the cycle with Cornell being my top choice overall, but it became my lowest choice of the NYC schools after interviewing.
Pros: Opportunities to do research with some of the best. Beautiful campus and nice location in the Upper East Side.
Cons: Out of the NYC schools I applied to, WCMC seems the least committed to underserved populations. They offer very limited merit-based aid, though I hear they are more generous with need-based aid.
Update: Withdrew
- View School >
University of Washington
- Applying for combined PhD/MSTP? No
- Submitted: Yes
- Secondary Completed: 08/30/2017
- Interview Invite: 09/13/2017
- Interview Attended: 10/23/2017
- Waitlisted: No
- Accepted: 11/19/2017
- Rejected: No
- Summary of Experience:
Mission statement sent: 7/12/17
Secondary received: 8/11/17
Interview Day: UW has separate interview days for in-region and out-of-region groups. Everyone on my day was out-of-region and all ~14 of us were from different states. The interview day started with socializing, a curriculum overview, a tour with a current student and a Q&A session with a faculty member. This was followed by lunch with current students. Our interviews were scheduled at various times in the afternoon. The interview format is a panel interview with three interviewers. The unique part of the interview is the role-playing scenarios where they give you a situation and ask you to act it out with one of the interviewers while the others observe. UW provides sample interview questions on their website.
Pros: The students here are very chill and the class seems tight-knit like a family. The faculty and administration are very friendly. I like the 1.5 year accelerated pre-clinical curriculum, though this is not unique to UW. I am interested in their underserved pathway and they have additional pathway options including Indian health, global health, Hispanic health and LGBTQ health.
Cons: Cost is high for out-of-region students, though students can apply for in-state residency after the first year. The facilities are a little old and gloomy. Step-1 scores are on the lower side.
Update: Awarded a non-resident tuition waiver for all 4 years of medical school!! This waiver is essentially a recruitment scholarship and covers the difference between in-state and out-of-state tuition without having to apply for WA state residency.
Update: Withdrew. Even with the non-resident waiver, this was one of my most expensive options.
- View School >
// Share //
×
Wait!
Are you sure you want to delete this application cycle? This will remove all application data and cannot be undone.
×
Wait!
Are you sure you want to delete this school? This will remove all application data and cannot be undone.